Search St. Marys Cottages

"Great location"

"My husband and I stayed for 3 nights with our dog and have a lovely time! The cottage was the perfect size for us and was very comfortable and quiet. The location was great too!"

"We really enjoyed our stay. Everything was perfect. Great view, big deck, spacious rooms. Owners were very communicative and helpful. Love the big book of recommendations. Thank you!"

"Generally speaking my wife and I had a comfortable stay but some pics of the exterior property must be old, it is kind of overgrown in the front and dead leaves were everywhere until a landscaping guy came, but he blew leaves all over our car and bikes that were on the front porch. Also, the entry keypad is not backlit so it is extremely hard to use. The only other things we thought were a bit off were that the dryer did not work very well at all, and the bathroom tub has moldy black caulking...

"Very clean and peaceful setting. Convenient to area stores and downtown. A little more info on where AC system thermostat and all other appliances info was would help."

"The 2 bedroom cottage was perfect for me and my 2 married friends to visit St Mary. They stayed in the queen bed room and me in the twin room. Really cute fenced in patio on the side and a separate covered front porch as well (we kept our bikes there while it rained). Great location for biking around St Mary and also taking the ferry to Cumberland Island!"

"Very comfortable house."

"The Peachtree Cottage is a real gem in St. Simons! Immaculately clean, very comfortable, nicely decorated, and in a perfect location. Owner was prompt and helpful in communications. We will return to this property. Highly recommended!"

"Quiet neighborhood except for an occasional plane overhead. So many more amenities and supplies than we expected. Lots of restaurants and stores within walking distance. EV charging connection. Note: 220v 50 amp receptacle. You will need your own adapter cable."

"My family, Bulldog Hank and I really enjoyed our stay. The house was our home for the week. Convenient to town and other areas with time to explore the islands. We will be back!"

"Would stay there again!"

"We traveled to Fernandina Beach to celebrate my daughter’s birthday with a short stay. We booked this property because my daughter was bringing friends and the bed situation in this house was just right. My daughter was able to stay with her friends in one bedroom while I had the other bedroom. There was also space in the main part of the house for a queen size air mattress. The house was very clean and as pictured in the listing photos so we were happy. We also enjoyed a couple of the features...

"We loved your property!"

"Our second year at the cottage and it was better than the first. Clean, comfortable and steps to the beach. We couldn’t have been happier with our two weeks here!"

"This was the perfect place for 2 families during a week long spring break trip. We had 4 teenage girls and 2 sets of parents. The accommodations were above and beyond. Beach chairs, umbrella and beach towels for all. The kitchen was very well stocked with all of the essentials and then some. We had a problem with the elevator upon arrival and needed it as we had a teenager with a torn ACL. The host was so sweet and very quick to send help and the elevator was up and going. We would definitely...

"The location is great with only steps to the pool. The pool pavilion is very nice and lots of shade. There is a very nice boardwalk to the beach. The house is very well stocked and comfortable seating for all in the general living area."

"Very cute cottage with everything you could need. Peaceful neighborhood. Great front screened in porch. Wonderful hostess with easy check-in and check-out. Cottage is close to many restaurants. Would stay at this rental again."

"It was the best location and such a wonderful home. We will be back!"

"Beautiful home!! Location was perfect!! It has everything you might need for your stay!! Resa was wonderful to work with. Responded to any questions we had during our stay. We will definitely stay here again! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️"

"Amazing, cozy getaway place, central located to pier village. You could not ask for anything more. The space, was warm and inviting and had all of the amenities that you would need for a perfect getaway. It was exceptionally clean, well stocked (towels, bed linens, etc) and the beds slept great. This is a place we love to stay at when we go and will definitely book it again in the future. As far as location you are within minutes of Pier Village, which is a very easy leisurely walk, as well as...

"It’s literally like home away from home. The rooms are tiny complete condos ♥️ and the board walk is awesome "

"Nice property and very relaxing."

"Very close to historical downtown and other shopping. What I didn’t like was dusty inside and the disposing of our trash was not super clear. Overall, I would not hesitate to stay there again or any other Tucker Stay property."